PopMusicology logo

Student Music Criticism

On Encouraging Critical Analysis of Popular Music in Undergraduate Students at the University of Pennsylvania

While teaching MUSC 1420: Thinking About Popular Music to over 60 UPenn undergraduates across the Fall 2024 and Spring 2025 semesters, I redesigned unit assignments around Music Notation & Contemporary Popular Music Definitions so students could pair historical readings—from race records and post-WWII pop to 1980s punk, post-soul, and 1990s divas—with their own critical song reviews.

These eleven curated reviews highlight how thoughtfully generalist listeners read popular music, featuring takes on The Waitresses’ “I Know What Boys Like,” Bill Withers’ “Lean On Me,” and Janet Jackson’s “What Have You Done For Me Lately?”, alongside classics by Dionne Warwick, Bessie Smith, Alberta Hunter, The Ronettes, Cameo, and Jimi Hendrix.

01

Over the Rainbow Judy Garland

ESSAY
02

I Know What Boys Like The Waitresses

ESSAY
03

Lean On Me Bill Withers

ESSAY
04

What Have You Done For Me Lately? Janet Jackson

ESSAY
05

I’ll Never Fall in Love Again Dionne Warwick

ESSAY
06

Gimme a Pigfoot and a Bottle of Beer Bessie Smith

ESSAY
07

Alfie Dionne Warwick

ESSAY
08

The Darktown Strutters’ Ball Alberta Hunter

ESSAY
09

Be My Baby The Ronettes

ESSAY
10

Candy Cameo

ESSAY
11

All Along the Watchtower Jimi Hendrix

BONUS

Music Notation Definitions: Thinking About Popular Music

My students and I crowdsourced definitions to musical notation terms in an activity called “Drop the Needle.” The Padlet linked below is a culmination of students extending musical notation into their own worlds, often informed by Pop.